Financial Fellowship Ask

Physician money, answered straight.

Contracts, student loans, insurance, and the attending transition, broken down by specialty and by the decision in front of you.

Ask your question

Financial Health AssessmentAnesthesiologyNew attending

Serena

Financial Health Assessment · FHA-011

Anesthesiology New attending · First year One income, no kids

Serena, 34, is an anesthesiologist in her first year as an attending, serving in the military in San Antonio. She is single with no kids, so one income carries the whole household. The assessment scores her 59 out of 100, in the Corrections band.

59

FHA score out of 100 · Corrections

$200,000

Student loans · income driven plan, refinance undecided

$250,000

Household income a year · military pay plus allowances

$20,000

Emergency fund · about three months of expenses

A lot is already working. The debt anchor earns full marks at 0.8 times income, the Tax Ladder is a perfect 8 of 8, and the TSP runs on automation at about 12 percent of income. Tricare covers her health care.

The gaps sit in two places. The Protection Stack has layers missing or borrowed from the military, and no written goals means the loan call has nothing to run through. Five fixes take the score to a 76.

59

FHA score out of 100 · Corrections

$250,000

Household income · military anesthesiologist, solo earner

$200,000

Student loans · income driven plan

76

Score with the five fixes · Stable band

Key takeaways

  • The score: 59 out of 100, in the Corrections band, and the shape is the story. The Tax Ladder earns a perfect 8 of 8 and the Physician Wealth Equation earns 12 of 14, while the Decision Filter earns 0 of 4.
  • About $200,000 of student loans sits on an income driven plan by default. The refinance call is still unmade, so the Transition loan box earns 0 of 6, even though she understands her service obligation in full.
  • The protection picture is mixed. Tricare, military malpractice cover, and SGLI at $500,000 are in place, but there is no umbrella policy, no individual disability policy, and a will with no documents behind it.
  • The money habits are real. She tracks spending, she can sort most dollars into lanes, and the TSP takes about 12 percent of income automatically before she ever sees the pay.
  • Five fixes move the score 17 points to a 76: make the loan decision, place a $500,000 umbrella, write three goals, fund the goals, and build the emergency fund to six months.

The taxes are perfect. The decision is still sitting there.

The Household

Serena is 34 and in her first year as an attending anesthesiologist. She serves in the military, stationed in San Antonio, with four years left on her service obligation, and she understands that commitment in full. She is single, with no kids, and hers is the only income.

Her household income is about $250,000 a year, military pay plus allowances. She rents, so there is no mortgage. Credit cards sit at $0 and get paid in full every month, and the car is paid off. The one large debt is the student loan balance.

One income, no safety net beyond the one she builds herself.

That balance is about $200,000, on an income driven plan right now. She has not decided whether to refinance, and the decision is still sitting there. Against about $250,000 of income, the debt anchor is 0.8 to 1.

Saving runs through the TSP, about 12 percent of income, taken out of her pay automatically. She holds about $80,000 invested overall. Her emergency fund is about $20,000, roughly three months of expenses, and she tracks her spending and can sort most dollars into categories.

On taxes, she sits in the 24 percent federal bracket and knows it. She uses the traditional TSP on purpose because of that bracket, and she also funds a Roth IRA. Two deliberate tax moves, both documented, both chosen with a reason.

Protection comes mostly from the uniform. Health cover is Tricare. Disability is whatever the military provides, with nothing individual on top. Life cover is SGLI at $500,000. Malpractice is covered through the military. She has a will from military legal assistance, and no goals written down.

Household factWhere it stands
CareerAnesthesiologist, first year as an attending, military
Age34
Household incomeAbout $250,000 a year, military pay plus allowances
Where she livesSan Antonio, rents
FamilySingle, no kids, solo earner
Student loansAbout $200,000, income driven plan, refinance undecided
Other debtNo mortgage, cards at $0 paid in full monthly, car paid off
Emergency fundAbout $20,000, about 3 months of expenses
SavingAbout 12 percent into the TSP, automated from pay
Invested assetsAbout $80,000
Taxes24 percent federal bracket, known; traditional TSP chosen for the bracket, plus a Roth IRA
DisabilityMilitary coverage only; no individual own occupation policy
Life insuranceSGLI $500,000, in force
UmbrellaNone
MalpracticeCovered through the military
Estate documentsWill only, through military legal assistance; no power of attorney, no healthcare directive
Service obligationUnderstood in full; 4 years remaining
GoalsNone written down

The Score: 59 out of 100

The Financial Health Assessment grades a household across the same seven frameworks and lands the total in a band. Serena scores 59, in the Corrections band. She is scored on the attending rubric, new attending fork.

20

Measures graded

7

Frameworks

59

Serena's score

The 3-Bucket Framework earns 10 of 20. Milestones earn the full 6 on a net of 5. The emergency fund earns 2 at about three months, named lanes earn 2 because most dollars sort, and goals funded earns 0 because no money flows to written goals.

The Physician Wealth Equation earns 12 of 14. The Debt Anchor takes the full 10: about $200,000 of debt against about $250,000 of income is 0.8 to 1, well under the new attending line of 3.0 times. Stretch saving earns 2 at about 12 percent.

The Protection Stack earns 12 of 22: health at the full 4 under Tricare, malpractice at the full 2 through the military, and disability, life, and estate documents at 2 each. Umbrella earns 0, because no policy exists. The Transition framework earns 4 of 10, all of it contract clarity.

The Tax Ladder earns a perfect 8 of 8. The Decision Filter earns 0 of 4 with zero written goals. The Lifestyle Guardrails earn 13 of 22: the savings floor at 6 for a rate of about 12 percent, the leak at 3 for tracked spending, and automation at the full 4.

FrameworkWhat it coversPoints
02 3-Bucket FrameworkMilestones 6 at a net of 5, emergency fund 2, named lanes 2, goals funded 010 of 20
03 Physician Wealth EquationDebt Anchor 10 at 0.8 times income, stretch saving 2 at about 12 percent12 of 14
04 Protection StackHealth 4, disability 2, life 2, umbrella 0, malpractice 2, estate documents 212 of 22
05 TransitionLoan call 0, the refinance decision unmade; contract clarity 4, service obligation understood4 of 10
06 Tax LadderRoth against pre tax 4, bracket plus moves 48 of 8
07 Decision FilterGoals written 0, nothing on paper0 of 4
08 Lifestyle GuardrailsSavings floor 6, the leak 3, wealth first automation 413 of 22
TotalCorrections band59 out of 100

Read the shape, not just the total. The earning, saving, and tax machinery is built and running. The missing points sit where a decision or a document is required: the loan call, the umbrella, the written goals, and the cushion under a single income.

The Two Frameworks Behind the Score

The score grades 20 measures across seven frameworks. Two of them carry this case: the Protection Stack, which scores 12 of 22 on a solo income, and the Decision Filter, which earns 0 of 4 because no goals are written down.

Framework one

The Protection Stack

The stack has six layers: health, disability, life, umbrella, malpractice, and estate. Each layer covers a different way the plan can fail. Serena has layers in place, and four of them come from the military. The framework earns 12 of 22.

The umbrella layer

There is no umbrella policy at all, which earns 0 of 4. A lawsuit away from work, a car accident for example, would be aimed at her and at her future income as an anesthesiologist.

Missing

Disability cover

Military disability coverage is the only layer, with no individual own occupation policy on top of it. Military cover is built around a rating and her service. It does not ask whether she can still work as an anesthesiologist. The box earns 2 of 4.

Partial

Estate documents

A will is in place, done through military legal assistance. There is no power of attorney and no healthcare directive, so the documents that cover her while she is alive and cannot act are missing. The box earns 2 of 4.

Partial

Framework two

The Decision Filter

Written goals with numbers and dates are the filter every money decision gets run through. Serena has no goals written down, so every call gets made with nothing to check against, and the framework earns 0 of 4.

Written goals

The written goal count is zero. No dollar amounts, no dates, nothing on paper for a decision to be measured against.

Missing

The loan call

About $200,000 of loans sits on an income driven plan, and the refinance decision is unmade. Nobody chose that plan as the plan. It is the plan because nothing replaced it.

Missing

Goals funded

With no written goals, no money flows toward any goal on a schedule. The TSP automation proves she can run this mechanic. It has no goals to point at yet.

Missing

What She Did Right

A 59 has real machinery under it. This is what is already built.

The Debt Anchor is full marks

About $200,000 of student debt against about $250,000 of income is 0.8 to 1, well under the new attending line of 3.0 times. Cards are at $0, the car is paid off, and there is no mortgage.

The Tax Ladder is perfect

She knows her 24 percent federal bracket, picked the traditional TSP on purpose because of it, and funds a Roth IRA on top. Two deliberate moves earn the full 8 of 8.

Health and malpractice are covered

Tricare covers her, the only member of the household, for the full 4 health points. Malpractice cover through the military earns the full 2.

Wealth gets paid first

About 12 percent of income goes into the TSP automatically, out of her pay before she sees it. Automation earns the full 4, and the savings floor earns 6 at that rate.

The milestone net is strong

Her positives outweigh the negatives by five on the milestone checklist, a net of 5, which earns the full 6 points. She also tracks spending and can sort most dollars into lanes.

Her service obligation is clear

She understands her service commitment and knows four years remain. Contract clarity earns the full 4.

The Layers the Uniform Did Not Bring

The first deep dive is the Protection Stack. She has no umbrella policy. Her disability cover is whatever the military provides, with nothing individual on top of it. Her estate plan is a will, with no power of attorney and no healthcare directive. She is the only income, with cash covering about three months.

Each layer covers a different failure. Health covers the medical bills. Disability covers the years she cannot work. Life covers the people who depend on her if she dies. Umbrella covers a lawsuit that has nothing to do with medicine. Malpractice covers what happens at work. Estate covers the moment she cannot act for herself.

There is no individual own occupation disability policy on the physician earner in this house, and she is the only earner.

The stack gets sized to the life she has now: single, no kids, renting. Nobody needs her to carry a giant life policy right now, and SGLI at $500,000 handles that layer at partial credit because SGLI is group cover, a policy she does not own herself.

Military benefits cover some layers, and that is the trap in this file. Tricare, SGLI, malpractice cover, and the military disability cover show up because of the uniform. When four layers arrive on their own, the whole stack can feel finished. The umbrella, the individual disability policy, and two estate documents never arrive on their own.

One more fact shapes this deep dive. She has four years of service left, and the layers the military gives her are tied to that service. When she separates, they change or they go away. Every layer she builds herself now comes with her.

The fix has three parts. Place a $500,000 umbrella policy, with the auto and renters liability limits under it checked. Price an individual own occupation disability policy through an agent who knows military physicians. Add the power of attorney and the healthcare directive at the legal assistance office that did her will.

A Decision Still Sitting There

The second deep dive is the Decision Filter. She has about $200,000 of student loans on an income driven plan, and the refinance decision is still unmade. She also has no written goals. Put those two facts together and every financial call is being made without a filter.

Written goals with numbers and dates are the filter every money decision gets run through. The loan question, the house question, and the savings question each get held up against the goals and asked which answer gets her there. Without a filter, she drifts, and the default picks the direction.

Nobody chose the income driven plan as the plan. It is the plan because nothing replaced it.

The loan answer changes with the goal. Finish the four years and go into private practice points one way. Stay in for a full career points another way. Refinance against staying federal cannot be answered in the abstract. Her goals answer it.

The filter also runs the Reversal Test: can this decision be undone. Military service is government employment, so it can count toward Public Service Loan Forgiveness while she is on a qualifying repayment plan. Refinancing federal loans into a private loan closes that door for good. Staying federal keeps the refinance open later.

One path can be reversed and the other cannot. That fact alone leaves the answer open, and it means the refinance deserves a written reason before she pulls the trigger, worked through with her own advisor and her real numbers.

The fix is to make the call. Pull the federal loan records, check how many payments have counted so far, run refinance against staying federal side by side, pick one, write down why, and put a date on it. Then write three goals with numbers and dates.

Milestones: A Net of Five

Inside the 3-Bucket Framework, the milestone checklist is where a new attending household shows its momentum. Serena nets 5 on the checklist. On the attending scale, a net of 5 or more earns the full 6 milestone points, and a net of 2 or less would earn 0.

The rest of the bucket picture sits around that net. Most dollars sort into the named lanes, which earns 2 of 4. The emergency fund, at about three months of expenses, earns 2 of 4. Nothing flows toward written goals, so goals funded earns 0.

Have a money question we have not answered?

If you have a question about a decision you are about to make, ask it here

The Prescription

Five moves, in the order the episode gave them.

1

Make the loan decision.

This is the Attending Transition Blueprint, and it gains 6 points, moving the loan call from 0 to 6. Run the math on refinancing against staying federal, counting any forgiveness credit her service may be earning.

Remember the Reversal Test, because the refinance is the one move she cannot take back. Make the call, write the reason, and execute it. For a new attending, the loan call is the biggest dollar decision of the first year.

2

Get a $500,000 umbrella policy.

This is the Protection Stack, and it gains 4 points, moving umbrella cover from 0 to 4. Zero cover on a physician income is a gap, even as a renter. Documented invested assets are about $80,000, and $500,000 sits at or above that rough asset base.

Line up the auto and renters liability limits under the policy so the umbrella has something to sit on. Of all five items, this one has the lowest cost for the most protection.

3

Write three goals with numbers and dates.

This is the Decision Filter, and it gains 2 points, moving goals written from 0 to 2. Three goals is the partial line on this box, and the filter has to exist before it can work. Each goal gets a dollar amount and a date, put somewhere she will see them.

The episode named examples in her own numbers. Emergency fund at $40,000 by next June. Loan strategy chosen and set up by the end of this quarter. Savings rate at 20 percent by the time she separates.

4

Fund the goals.

This is the 3-Bucket Framework, and it gains 3 points, moving goals funded from 0 to 3. A written goal with no money behind it is a wish. Give each goal a monthly dollar amount and set up an automatic transfer.

She already runs this mechanic with the TSP and it works. Dollars flowing to the goals on automation, short of fully funded, is exactly what this step asks for.

5

Build the emergency fund to six months.

This is the 3-Bucket Framework, the Safety Net, and it gains 2 points, moving the emergency fund from 2 to 4. Three months is thin when she is the only earner. Six months for her is roughly $40,000, up from about $20,000 today.

The military is going to move her, and the Safety Net keeps her stable through every move and through the separation at the end of her service obligation.

Run all five and the arithmetic is 59 plus 17, a score of 76. The gains are 6 for the loan call, 4 for the umbrella, 2 for three written goals, 3 for funding the goals, and 2 for the six month emergency fund. A score of 76 out of 100 moves Serena into the Stable band.

What This Case Teaches

Benefits that arrive on their own can hide the layers that never do. Serena gets health cover, group life cover, and malpractice cover from her service, and all three are real. The umbrella, the individual disability policy, the power of attorney, and the healthcare directive need a decision and a signature from her.

A decision left unmade still picks a direction. The default picks it.

The second lesson is about the filter. Her taxes are perfect and her automation runs, and the biggest loan decision of her first attending year still sits unmade, because no written goals exist to answer it. Three lines on paper, each with a number and a date, turn that drift into a call.

Questions this case answers

What score did Serena receive on the Financial Health Assessment?

Serena scored 59 out of 100, in the Corrections band. The Tax Ladder is a perfect 8 of 8 and the Physician Wealth Equation earns 12 of 14, while the Protection Stack earns 12 of 22 and the Decision Filter earns 0 of 4.

How does a household earning about $250,000 score 59 out of 100?

Nothing in the seven frameworks pays for income itself. The boxes pay for the debt ratio, the savings rate, and the protection in force. Serena earns full marks on the debt anchor at 0.8 times income and on both tax boxes, and she loses points where a decision or a document is missing: no umbrella policy, no written goals, an unmade loan call, and an emergency fund at about three months on a solo income.

What is the first fix for Serena?

Make the loan decision. About $200,000 sits on an income driven plan by default, and the refinance call is unmade. Run refinancing against staying federal side by side, counting any forgiveness credit her service may be earning, and remember the Reversal Test: refinancing into a private loan cannot be undone, while staying federal keeps that door open. Make the call, write the reason, and execute it.

What do the five fixes do to Serena's score?

Run all five and the arithmetic is 59 plus 17, a score of 76. The gains are 6 for the loan decision, 4 for a $500,000 umbrella policy, 2 for three written goals, 3 for funding the goals, and 2 for building the emergency fund to six months, roughly $40,000. A score of 76 out of 100 moves Serena into the Stable band.

Sources and Basis

This assessment is built from the household's record in the show's year end case bank: the build brief, the episode script, and the governed packet for Serena, a military anesthesiology household. Every figure on this page comes from that record, and the score is traced box by box under the locked attending rubric.

The attending rubric weights the seven frameworks at 20, 14, 22, 10, 8, 4, and 22, for a total of 100. The bands are Needs a workup from 0 to 39, Corrections from 40 to 69, Stable from 70 to 84, and Healthy from 85 to 100. New attendings are scored on the Transition fork: the loan call, and contract clarity.

Written by Ryan Inman, MBA, MAFM. Last updated October 2026.

About

Ryan Inman is a retired financial planner who worked with about 500 physician families. He created the Financial Residency podcast (about 3 million downloads) and is no longer affiliated with it. Financial Fellowship is his sole focus. This guide is educational. Last updated October 2026.

If you have a question about a decision you are about to make, ask it here

Have a money question we have not answered?

If you have a question about a decision you are about to make, ask it here.

Ask your question

If you have a question about a decision you are about to make, ask it here

Ask your question

Education for physicians. Run the numbers against your own contract, specialty, and state, and confirm moves with your licensed planner, CPA, or attorney.